| E | 2-10 | E25 | Start of OT quarter, clock 12:00. |
| | | BELFRY WINS TOSS, BELFRY WILL BE ON DEFENSE AND DEFEND NORTH GOAL |
| E | 2-10 | E25 | ETOWN ball on BELFRY10. |
| E | 2-G | B10 | 1st and 10. |
| E | 1-G | B10 | JONATHAN RUSHER rush up middle for 4 yards to the BELFRY6 (CLIF. HATFIELD). |
| E | 2-G | B06 | CHRIS TODD pass intercepted by PAUL HOWARD at the BELFRY0, PAUL HOWARD return 0 yards to the BELFRY0, touchback. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 0 yards, TOP 00:06 |
| B | 1-10 | B20 | BELFRY drive start at 12:00 (OT ). |
| B | 1-10 | B20 | BELFRY ball on ETOWN10. |
| B | 1-G | E10 | DOUG HOWARD rush over left tackle for 3 yards to the ETOWN7 (TAYLOR RIGNEY). |
| B | 2-G | E07 | DAVID JONES rush up middle for 4 yards to the ETOWN3 (DREW MURPHY). |
| B | 3-G | E03 | TYLER BOSTIC rush up middle for 2 yards to the ETOWN1 (TAYLOR RIGNEY;DREW MURPHY). |
| B | 4-G | E01 | Timeout ETOWN, clock 12:00. |
| B | 4-G | E01 | DAVID JONES rush up middle for 1 yard to the ETOWN0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 12:00. |
| | | BELFRY 33, ETOWN 27 |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 10 yards, TOP 00:00 |
| | | BELFRY 33, ETOWN 27 |